With $600 CAC, $100 monthly ARPA, 75% margin and 3% monthly churn, simple payback is 8.0 months and churn-adjusted payback is 9.0 months. Change the figures to compare recovery time, surviving customers and the lifetime margin available to cover CAC.
What payback answers
Payback asks how long acquisition spending stays tied up before a cohort earns it back. It helps connect a sales plan to the cash needed to support that plan. A profitable customer relationship can still put pressure on cash if the acquisition bill arrives long before the margin that repays it.
Start with consistent inputs. CAC includes the acquisition expenses you intend to recover, divided by new customers from the matching period. Use the CAC calculator to build that figure. ARPA is monthly revenue per account, and gross margin is the share left after delivering the service. Match both to the same customer cohort rather than mixing a new segment's CAC with an older segment's revenue.
Simple versus churn-adjusted recovery
Monthly gross margin equals ARPA multiplied by gross margin percentage. Simple payback divides CAC by that monthly amount. It assumes the customer keeps paying, so it provides a useful starting point but misses losses from cancellations.
This model assumes constant monthly churn, constant ARPA and gross margin, margin paid monthly, no discounting and CAC paid up front. Its timing convention credits the first month's margin before the first churn reduction. The second month's expected margin is reduced by one month's churn. It describes an average across a cohort, not a promise that an individual customer will stay.
Monthly gross margin = ARPA × margin / 100
Simple months = CAC / monthly gross margin
Cumulative margin after n months = monthly gross margin × (1 − (1 − churn)^n) / churn
Churn is a fraction in the formula: 3% becomes 0.03. At zero churn, the cumulative formula reduces to monthly margin multiplied by months. At positive churn, solve it using logarithms. The result includes fractional months for comparison; with payments credited only at month end, recovery occurs in the next complete month.
Work through the default example
The hypothetical account produces $100 × 75% = $75 monthly gross margin. Simple payback is $600 / $75 = 8.0 months. With 3% churn, lifetime gross margin is $75 / 0.03 = $2,500, and cumulative margin becomes 2,500 × (1 − 0.97^n).
Set cumulative margin equal to $600. Then 0.97^n = 0.76, so n = ln(0.76) / ln(0.97) = 9.01 months, displayed as 9.0 months. The active share at the fractional payback point is 76.0%; at month nine, 0.97^9 also rounds to 76.0%. Because 9.01 is slightly above nine, the first full monthly payment that covers acquisition cost arrives in month 10.
The table shows expected cumulative gross profit and the amount still to recover. It stops at 24 months for readability. A later recovery point still appears in the result. These expected amounts need not match a small cohort's actual collections.
When acquisition cost never comes back
At $3,000 CAC with the same revenue, margin and churn, lifetime margin remains $2,500. The calculator therefore says does not pay back at this churn. Adding more months cannot close the gap. When CAC exactly equals the lifetime limit, cumulative margin approaches that limit but never reaches it at a finite month, so that case also has no finite payback.
Use the LTV calculator to inspect the lifetime calculation. The LTV:CAC guide explains why a ratio alone cannot establish acquisition quality. A favorable ratio and a manageable cash recovery period answer different questions.
Choose a target deliberately
David Skok's original SaaS guidance, written around 2011, helped establish recovery within 12 months as a common convention; his later definitions explicitly qualify it. It is not a universal rule or a guarantee of sustainable spending. Your runway, payment terms, retention evidence and service costs determine whether a particular delay is affordable.
Select CAC to calculate the acquisition cost recoverable within your chosen target. With churn, this uses expected cumulative margin over that horizon. Annual prepayments, expansion, refunds, delayed collections, taxes and fixed overhead are outside this model. Build a separate cash forecast before treating gross-margin payback as cash in the bank.